Is Yuuki jealous of HW ?

After reading a lot of recent posts stating Kaname loved HW more than Yuuki .

I want to know :

1- Who do you think Kaname loved more : Yuuki or HW ?

2- A reasonable explanation why Kaname love your girl of your choice .

3- Your opinion if Yuuki is jealous of HW and why ?

1. I think that he has stated over and over again, who he loves more, and in this chapter he confirms it once more saying that he gave her Artemis so that he could be killed by her hands if they are not together its sad and dramatic...

2. I should bring all the manga forward? LOL you know what I mean, there is nothing in his past with the ancestor (from what we saw) that can be compared to this.

3. For me she has no reasons to be jealous, Kaname has said in the past "only you.." and he never given her any reason to doubt his love confessions.

By the way this argument with the HW from where does it come from? because I do not see any relation between love and Kaname's actions in the present. Isn't that kaname has chosen this way (that the HW) had suggested in order to kill the source of menaces that could possibly hurt the mankind and Yuuki? if it was not for Yuuki, Kaname perhaps should have preferred the slumber solution as he did in the past.

Only for the one that he cared to protect and build a safe place, he went in all of these trouble, fighting the council, ending Rido, re-establishing the Kurans, she had been his reason and his flame, Yuuki, not someone dead.

Who do you think Kaname loved more : Yuuki or HW ?

The answer is obvious - kaname loves yuuki. nothing from manga proved that the HW weights more than yuuki. On contraire, kaname confessed his love for yuuki - "I love you more than anyone else in the entire world."

Also, kaname latest reactions proves that he loves her: when accidentely inflicted a scratch on her cheek he wiped away the blood. More important was the look he had while doing it, it was soft, filled with love. And yuuki's gaze didn't dissapoint either.

A reasonable explanation why Kaname love your girl of your choice .

This is hard I would preffer kaname to love me but he is madly in love with yuuki so I would cheer up for him. what I won't do for kaname

Your opinion if Yuuki is jealous of HW and why ?

Kaname gave her no reason to be jealous but this doesn't mean she cannot be. For her whole life she's in love with kaname, and suddenly she find out about the existence of another one in kaname's past.
Even if kaname assured her that he didn't replace HW with her however the feeling of jealousy cannot be stopped.

some how i think that to some exstent yuki is jealous of the hooded woman. for one thing, i to feel kina ill at the thought of kaname making love to someone other then yuki (i think yuki does to). i mean its not like the kuran family is just gunna start on it's own kaname must have made love to someone weather its the hooded woman or some other girl(god i hope not) but i do belive that kaname loves yuki more and yuki knows this which is proberly why she tryed to attack him. it was her way of seeing if he were caperble to killing her if he could not it would mean that he loves her and can't let her go. and i gess it was also her way of makeing sure that he wont go and kill sara.

1- Who do you think Kaname loved more : Yuuki or HW ?

Well I have to state the self-evident? Okay … then … HW … hm; who exactly is she again??? … well compared with Yuuki I couldn’t resist …

On a serious mode and trying to stick only to what we know from the manga I wonder how a small attachment that he felt for the HW can ever be compared with these lines for Yuuki >>

Yuuki … please. ONLY YOU…

I love you. More than anyone else in the entire world.

The one who warms his heart is the tender existence … that is his ONLY ONE

How many countless nights did I spend in vain? I have finally got hold of the girl I love and with whom I will be spending millions of nights. etc etc…

And something lastly … does anyone really can picture Kaname if he would have seen Yuuki to turn into crystals before his own eyes to be in that state??? >>

http://www.mangahere.com/manga/vampire_knight/v13/c064/5.html
http://www.mangahere.com/manga/vampire_knight/v13/c064/7.html
http://www.mangahere.com/manga/vampire_knight/v13/c064/8.html
http://www.mangahere.com/manga/vampire_knight/v13/c064/12.html

The question is rhetorical …

Juliet wrote: By the way this argument with the HW from where does it come from? because I do not see any relation between love and Kaname's actions in the present. Isn't that kaname has chosen this way (that the HW) had suggested in order to kill the source of menaces that could possibly hurt the mankind and Yuuki? if it was not for Yuuki, Kaname perhaps should have preferred the slumber solution as he did in the past.

Hahaha … do you really wanna answer you from where it stems??? Nope … I know

2- A reasonable explanation why Kaname love your girl of your choice .

Now you hit a nerve there … my question exactly! And also Yuuki’s question as well >>

My strong … beautiful Kaname … why would you want me?
http://www.mangahere.com/manga/vampire_knight/v11/c052/17.html

Why; why; why????? *squeals*

Now there is always the theory that Yuuki could be the reincarnation of Kaname’s wife in the past i.e. of the first Queen with whom he started the Kuran clan. I’m fond of that theory cuz IMO would tie up many unexplained hints that Hino has left here and there.

But regardless of this theory the way that I see Yuuki through Kaname’s eyes and Yume destined love is that she was born because he awakened … she was born for him and not because it happened to be born a Kuran she was destined to be his.
There is this slightest difference but yet makes all the difference …

He saw her in the distant past in her form as she is now … she influenced the past by naming the scythe, Artemis …

Solely from that scene and only IMO Hino stresses the importance of Yuuki’s existence in Kaname’s life …

3- Your opinion if Yuuki is jealous of HW and why ?

aya-chan wrote: Kaname gave her no reason to be jealous but this doesn't mean she cannot be. For her whole life she's in love with kaname, and suddenly she find out about the existence of another one in kaname's past.
Even if kaname assured her that he didn't replace HW with her however the feeling of jealousy cannot be stopped.

I second that!
Yes I also think she could be because HW was an important woman in Kaname’s life … he may not have been so much romantically and deeply involved with her but still for a woman in love who also see herself “unworthy” to have this man isn’t strange. Yuuki had her own insecurities as a woman … We saw her jealousy when she thought that the HW gave to Kaname his name >>
http://www.mangahere.com/manga/vampire_knight/v13/c066/20.html
http://www.mangahere.com/manga/vampire_knight/v13/c066/21.html

That woman she first called you this name…

She was jealous of Sara when he saw Kaname greeting her with a hand-kissing and also I think she was jealous when she thought that Kaname might have done something to Ruka again … something similar to what he had done years ago when he bitten her >>
http://www.mangahere.com/manga/vampire_knight/v13/c066/16.html
http://www.mangahere.com/manga/vampire_knight/v13/c066/17.html

So in other words why not; to not feel jealous of the HW? Eros has this trait of possessiveness …
And maybe Kaname tried to play this card to Yuuki in his desperate attempt to make her give up on him … to feel betrayed …

yukikuran90210 wrote: i to feel kina ill at the thought of kaname making love to someone other then yuki (i think yuki does to). i mean its not like the kuran family is just gunna start on it's own kaname must have made love to someone weather its the hooded woman or some other girl

Hahaha … she felt jealous cuz the HW was the FIRST who called his name … imagine if she was his first elsewhere as well

But think about the poor guy … how he could withstand millennia without sex???
Here I wonder how he could stand without in his current life

Well as far as I remember you are very young so it is natural to see this issue in that way but believe me a man has to have some experience in this particular area … so personally I wouldn’t mind if the HW had taught him a few “moves”

What it counts is that Yuuki comes first into his heart and for that we can be certain.

Well, of course he loves Yuki. But the HW could mean more to him than her. And everything Kaname said when she was human was THEN. NOW he puts the HW FIRST. He wants to fulfill HER wishes, not caring what Yuki wants.

SassyKnight wrote:Well, of course he loves Yuki. But the HW could mean more to him than her. And everything Kaname said when she was human was THEN. NOW he puts the HW FIRST. He wants to fulfill HER wishes, not caring what Yuki wants.

I disagree with you, Sassy. There's no evidence that Kaname puts the hooded woman first. The only thing that Kaname fears the most is his fiancee Yuuki being killed by either someone or himself. If he doesn't what Yuuki wants, he'll be not only become out of character and context, but also a double-edged sword.

I feel Kaname is nostalgic torward the HW, he had to take the risk to kill all the purebloods just for her,gosh. He's hidden his past and feelings well, he's got us guessing on so many "what ifs', buts', and i thinks'"

It's pretty overwhelming...
but i'm pretty sure Kaname is just taking a different route to save Yuuki from the dangers he predicted.

SassyKnight wrote:Well, of course he loves Yuki. But the HW could mean more to him than her. And everything Kaname said when she was human was THEN. NOW he puts the HW FIRST. He wants to fulfill HER wishes, not caring what Yuki wants.

I'm alittle confused here.... Are you saying Kname loved Yuki as a human and his feelings changed now she is his PB fiance?

The HW, proved to be a wise woman, that tought him many things. On the other hand, Yuki, is just an ignorant child. Love, has nothing to do with it! Any person who gets bossed around out of love, is pathetic.

i don't think yuki is jelous of anyone because if you remember kaname said "that no one can replace someone else"

SassyKnight wrote:Well, of course he loves Yuki. But the HW could mean more to him than her. And everything Kaname said when she was human was THEN. NOW he puts the HW FIRST. He wants to fulfill HER wishes, not caring what Yuki wants.

Actually, the HW-Hooded woman, is just a sensei- teacher, to him.
I don't really think he would have any extra feelings for her... Its just that, she is wise, and Kaname is really just protectikng Yuki. And if Kaname were to do everything that Yuki wants, and agrees with... Thats just not Kaname.

mariangie wrote:After reading a lot of recent posts stating Kaname loved HW more than Yuuki .

I want to know :

1- Who do you think Kaname loved more : Yuuki or HW ?

2- A reasonable explanation why Kaname love your girl of your choice .

3- Your opinion if Yuuki is jealous of HW and why ?

1- Definitely Yuki/Yuuki

2- Because, Kaname said so himself, that no one could replace her... Something along those lines... He said that to Yuki. Not the HW LOL
And, lets be reaslistic here, would Kaname really love the hooded woman?? He has only ever loved two women-1. The first female vampire... and 2. Yuki
Unless the HW is actually that very same first female vampire than wow ... But I doubt...

3- Yuki might be jealous of HW, because Kaname is really only focusing on her. Maybe Yuki thought that things would be more lovey dovey with her and Kaname. Shes just probably freaking out also, because she might think that she was all apart of his game... Not of actual love. And that her heart is now going to be crushed, and played with, and cheated on... BUT HE DOESN'T LOVE HER(HOODED WOMAN)! HE LOVES YOU YUKI!

i think yuuki is jealous of hooded woman because in her eyes she stole kaname from him even after her death.love you hino for making this story so tragic but so great,you are true writer not someone like crappy twilight.love you hino,just love you.