Why is it so bad that Kaname killed shizuka?

I wonder why it is so bad to kill someone who is equally bad...
well, everyone keeps on telling me it was soo bad of him to do...because shizuka was a pure blood

No, oh none of you are idiots, im sorry,i didn't really know how to word the question. But shizuka was killed for a reason, was she bad? And was the reason bad? (hope that helps!!)

I agree

fix the spelling in your title. Its SHIZUKA not SHIZUKU.

and to the question, who is asking that question?? this is confusing. I have no problem with him killing her

I actually like him more for killing her and i am not saying this because i hate her she was a fun character that is all

Sweet, is right. It's Shizuka not Shizuku

I don't think that it was wrong of him. He had to. I really liked Shizuka, but I understand completely.

kill someone who is equally bad...

Um, I'm not sure of the meaning of the above quote Shadow96.

I think shadow is refering to this:

Shizuka only had to die because they're all idiots and could never work together, they had a common enemy and kaname knew it and had Sara bitten Yuuki, it would have just awoken her pureblood.

It even wasn't necessary for Kaname to be the one to kill her. Zero would have killed Shizuka for his own petty reasons and been stronger (having her blood) for it. But Kaname wanted *more* power to protect Yuuki, so he stepped in and took her blood. Even though Zero has technically been the one to protect her or save her and yuuki wouldn't be in much danger after she became a pureblood. So I kinda see it as overkill as his excuse being the most powerful pureblood vampire around.

the only virtue it has, is that Zero is prevented from technically being Shizuka's killer, although Ichiru does blame him anyway and later resolved to blame Rido as the instigator of it.

Let's not forget the true fact that Shizuka had murdered Zero's family... and the young hunter have seen it all. If she would have lived, Zero would have been in the same position that Kaname had become... a slave.

Shadow96 wrote:I wonder why it is so bad to kill someone who is equally bad...
well, everyone keeps on telling me it was soo bad of him to do...because shizuka was a pure blood

You mean why killing a pureblood is considered as a taboo in the vampire society? so Shizuka's murder is considered to be "bad" under their social norms or that is something immoral that the fandom accuses Kaname of, or as an act is bad for Kaname (meaning the consequences after killing a pureblood)?

feel as an idiot, but I have not understand completely get it!

juliet wrote:

Shadow96 wrote:I wonder why it is so bad to kill someone who is equally bad...
well, everyone keeps on telling me it was soo bad of him to do...because shizuka was a pure blood

You mean why killing a pureblood is considered as a taboo in the vampire society? so Shizuka's murder is considered to be "bad" under their social norms or that is something immoral that the fandom accuses Kaname of, or as an act is bad for Kaname (meaning the consequences after killing a pureblood)?

feel as an idiot, but I have not understand completely get it!

I don't either. You aren't alone. It could be anyone of those things.

It also kinda sounds like it: Why is it so bad for Kaname to kill someone as bad as him?

I really don't get it.

Divine Rose wrote:

juliet wrote:

Shadow96 wrote:I wonder why it is so bad to kill someone who is equally bad...
well, everyone keeps on telling me it was soo bad of him to do...because shizuka was a pure blood

You mean why killing a pureblood is considered as a taboo in the vampire society? so Shizuka's murder is considered to be "bad" under their social norms or that is something immoral that the fandom accuses Kaname of, or as an act is bad for Kaname (meaning the consequences after killing a pureblood)?

feel as an idiot, but I have not understand completely get it!

I don't either. You aren't alone. It could be anyone of those things.

It also kinda sounds like it: Why is it so bad for Kaname to kill someone as bad as him?

I really don't get it.

Thanks! I was beginning to wonder what I missed. Shadow if you want a more clear answer can you please go in clarifying it better?

I wonder why it is so bad to kill someone who is equally bad... confused
well, everyone keeps on telling me it was soo bad of him to do...because shizuka was a pure blood

Because purebloods are really rare and well respected. They are placed in a position of power, like lords, ladies and masters. Anyway, killing someone because they are bad is still bad. I'm not going to say that I'm not on Kaname's side in this one, because I am. Shizuka deserved to die and Kaname needs the power he took to be able to kill the Council. Killing the council was also bad though, but I also feel they deserved to be killed at the same time.

Anyway, saying that what Kaname did was bad is understandable to me. And I'm not even going to say so otherwise. But hating him for it is way beyond my understanding. It's merely an excuse some fans use to hate him. Some people do wrong things to correct other wrongs. I'm not going to say its justifiable. Its just how it is. XD

Shadow96 wrote:I wonder why it is so bad to kill someone who is equally bad... confused
well, everyone keeps on telling me it was soo bad of him to do...because shizuka was a pure blood

just as bad kaname is not bad. maybe i didnt understand what you said.

well i really dont care if he killed her.well isnt she the woman who once said to kaname when he was a kid what a sad fate to be born to kurans and when she was dying then too. well i didnt hate her but she is dead well i am not bothered.

because purebloods are very less and revered thats why, its considered bad to kill a pureblood. but the woman was mad after her lover's death. kaname did a favour to her by letting her go to him.

Shadow96 wrote:I wonder why it is so bad to kill someone who is equally bad...
well, everyone keeps on telling me it was soo bad of him to do...because shizuka was a pure blood

shizuka was the one who came into academy to kill kaname. kaname did not search for her to kill her and took her powers, she came to him. it was an one on one battle. it win the one who was smartest.

Knightmare wrote:Shizuka only had to die because they're all idiots and could never work together, they had a common enemy and kaname knew it and had Sara bitten Yuuki, it would have just awoken her pureblood.

It even wasn't necessary for Kaname to be the one to kill her. Zero would have killed Shizuka for his own petty reasons and been stronger (having her blood) for it. But Kaname wanted *more* power to protect Yuuki, so he stepped in and took her blood. Even though Zero has technically been the one to protect her or save her and yuuki wouldn't be in much danger after she became a pureblood. So I kinda see it as overkill as his excuse being the most powerful pureblood vampire around.

the only virtue it has, is that Zero is prevented from technically being Shizuka's killer, although Ichiru does blame him anyway and later resolved to blame Rido as the instigator of it.

Shizuka did not came into academy with an alliance in mind. her goal was to kill kaname with yuuki as asassin.

And something else, zero never could have killed shizuka. maybe he had the power to release himself from under mind control *he replaced her control with pain* and shot her few times, but the final blow he never could provide it.

sweetsolace wrote:
and to the question, who is asking that question?? this is confusing. I have no problem with him killing her

I have no problem either.

aya-chan wrote:Shizuka did not came into academy with an alliance in mind. her goal was to kill kaname with yuuki as asassin.

And something else, zero never could have killed shizuka. maybe he had the power to release himself from under mind control *he replaced her control with pain* and shot her few times, but the final blow he never could provide it.

I agree. Zero could have never killed Shizuka just like Kaname could never kill Rido. Both can severely wound them, but never deliver the final blow. No matter how much Zero thought he could, he could never.

Uhm,
I didn't like that he killed shizuka
but it did make me like him more as a character because of that

I did like shizuka though, it's good that she's dead in a way, but i'd like to see some more flashbacks with her

Divine Rose wrote:

aya-chan wrote:Shizuka did not came into academy with an alliance in mind. her goal was to kill kaname with yuuki as asassin.

And something else, zero never could have killed shizuka. maybe he had the power to release himself from under mind control *he replaced her control with pain* and shot her few times, but the final blow he never could provide it.

I agree. Zero could have never killed Shizuka just like Kaname could never kill Rido. Both can severely wound them, but never deliver the final blow. No matter how much Zero thought he could, he could never.

I second this.

sweetsolace wrote:

Divine Rose wrote:

aya-chan wrote:Shizuka did not came into academy with an alliance in mind. her goal was to kill kaname with yuuki as asassin.

And something else, zero never could have killed shizuka. maybe he had the power to release himself from under mind control *he replaced her control with pain* and shot her few times, but the final blow he never could provide it.

I agree. Zero could have never killed Shizuka just like Kaname could never kill Rido. Both can severely wound them, but never deliver the final blow. No matter how much Zero thought he could, he could never.

I second this.

I third this!

nina wrote:

sweetsolace wrote:

Divine Rose wrote:

I agree. Zero could have never killed Shizuka just like Kaname could never kill Rido. Both can severely wound them, but never deliver the final blow. No matter how much Zero thought he could, he could never.

I second this.

I third this!

I fourth this!!!!!!

I never thought Kaname killing Shizuka was a moral issue: it was pretty much self defense for Kaname.

I am confused about the dark future Shizuka was predicting for Kaname. Is she hinting that having too many different people's pureblood makes one unstable? Too much power or too many blood slaves or something?

caela wrote:I never thought Kaname killing Shizuka was a moral issue: it was pretty much self defense for Kaname.

I am confused about the dark future Shizuka was predicting for Kaname. Is she hinting that having too many different people's pureblood makes one unstable? Too much power or too many blood slaves or something?

Ah , I always thought she ment that killing someone has it's consequences for yourself. Like in a moral way. If you kill one person, it will make it easier to kill a next one. The line is thinner.

But it could be indeed the things you mentioned too.

sweetsolace wrote:fix the spelling in your title. Its SHIZUKA not SHIZUKU.

and to the question, who is asking that question?? this is confusing. I have no problem with him killing her

lol u say it so smoothly... but Kaname killing her was to gain power obviously protect Yuuki in the future, but i think i read something about her wanting to die anyway somewhere in the manga.

DarkRose wrote:

sweetsolace wrote:fix the spelling in your title. Its SHIZUKA not SHIZUKU.

and to the question, who is asking that question?? this is confusing. I have no problem with him killing her

lol u say it so smoothly... but Kaname killing her was to gain power obviously protect Yuuki in the future, but i think i read something about her wanting to die anyway somewhere in the manga.

Yeah she wanted to die because her only love died and without saying her anything before
T.T
I Think it would be the same as Kaname

lililovelilica wrote:

DarkRose wrote:

sweetsolace wrote:fix the spelling in your title. Its SHIZUKA not SHIZUKU.

and to the question, who is asking that question?? this is confusing. I have no problem with him killing her

lol u say it so smoothly... but Kaname killing her was to gain power obviously protect Yuuki in the future, but i think i read something about her wanting to die anyway somewhere in the manga.

Yeah she wanted to die because her only love died and without saying her anything before
T.T
I Think it would be the same as Kaname

Yes Kaname wouldn´t try to continue his life when Yuuki dies. He would gladly accept the death by Zero (don´t want to say that he would do that but it would be possible)

Shizuka lost an impotant thing in her life, we´ve seen that she tried to gain power by killing Kaname to get revenge...she got it like this too...She didn´t really fighted against Kaname...it´s not so terrible in my eyes

I think Kaname killed Shizuka to protect Yuuki, she was almost giving her life for Zero and Kaname. And Shizuka would have killed her anyway just for revenge. When Kaname killed Shizuka she was save.

MissKuran wrote:I think Kaname killed Shizuka to protect Yuuki, she was almost giving her life for Zero and Kaname. And Shizuka would have killed her anyway just for revenge. When Kaname killed Shizuka she was save.

He did it fot Yuuki, it's obvious. Kaname wanted to break up the bond between Zero and Shizouka because only in that case Zero could achieve Kaname's goal.