I agree but this is something that remains to be seen since we do not know yet the real intentions of Kaname and secondly by showing the dead-end that Kaname was driven, it could be his justification but synchronously that there wasn’t any other way.
Wasn’t there any other way in order though to achieve what?
The destruction of all pureblood or the savor of even the few innocents such as Yuuki?
Because at the scene with the HW we see and that’s a fact that her plans of destruction come without distinctions/
What happens next?
Kaname tells her that he shall succeed her and this fact stops the attack. There we see it...
fact > HW tries to kill them all > Kaname stops her attack
Now in a plan/resolution that all pureblood are supposed to die as the only way to co-existence and some have to die (Kaname, Issue, Touma) obligatory to serve this purpose, one way or the other, either at the course or at the end...why Hino chooses to stop HW’s attack that apparently would give an end to this problem/conflict that is going on for centuries now?
What is the meaning of stopping HW’s attack if Kaname is there only to change with her roles and continue with the elimination?
Why the swift of roles? The successor role what purposes does it serve under this light? HW could have ended them all there and that would apparently solve the problem.
Is it only for Yuuki’s sake?> in this case then Hino intends to leave Yuuki as the sole pureblood in the world whereas all others will have been killed to serve the co-existence purposes...
If there is a window there for Yuuki, could’t that include and other pureblood are well that are innocent?
There you said a key phrase innocent lives … did Hino show that PBs are innocent beings; or the contrary?
Because what I see is an effort to shift the burden of the evilness mostly on the PBs … as if they cease to exist; it will cease the evil too. An easy way out if you ask me but still it could be it lol
There I see a great unbalance in the script which makes me wonder about Hino’s views and final direction.
Because who are the innocent/good PBs in the story? Except from the Kurans and maybe Isaya (who is a question mark) … who else?
let’s go over how many pureblood have remained now?
http://www.mangareader.net/104-40425-29/vampire-knight/chapter-56.htmlIs Touma’s sister also guilty? Hanadagi’s family that slept in the centuries? other family members that might have been left?
and who was the mean pureblood in this chapter? Sara, just Sara...
Touma did nothing in reality > attacked another pureblood that cannot be killed. Is it a coincidence that he survived?
The truth is that Hino left us with the idea that all families still had members other than Touma and Hios and Hana...
I am not saying that Hino cannot follow this easy way out, I am just judging it in advance as a theory >
Hino showed that the problem is by far more complex, is not a problem that focuses on pureblood solely but indeed spreads in many directions>
Nobles wanting to eat humans> Asato and the council are an amazing demonstration of that and it proves that if vampires want to take over humanity they do not have to be pureblood to do it. OR this or Asato’s menace was not a menace at all (since he could not change humans) and since the only problem that HW sees is the pureblood, and this is the only way out for a peaceful co-existence, then why do we blame Asato?
Going in the extermination of all under the reason that there is no other way out, purifies even Asato’s plans to kill all pureblood> and at the same time his own plan that saw humans as food totally nullifies HW’s perception that this problem can be solved only with the elimination of the pureblood and screams at the same time how empty this extermination plan sounds.
So why so much persistence in the pureblood race? HW’wish seems to be stacked like ten thousand of years ago when pureblood where indeed the enemy recruiting armies but the society has even progressed from there. More and more are wanting power, hunters even collaborated with the council > can this culture be changed with killing the purebloods?
Even Rima showed that they have no one to protect them against the hunters....
This is calling for laws and slow adaptation, a change in culture...better guardians.
Doesn’t seem that it was indeed in vain? Except from the project weapons-hunters which indeed saved the human race, still the longed co-existence never came. And through Sara’s plans and Asato’s in the past Hino showed us how close the doom could be, only from one PB.
No that’s not true...they were not all in vain. Hino sheds rays of light that the slow way’s in fact started to make a change already...
> The nightclass protected the day-class> the day-class was aware of vampires existence (a great fact since the vampire’s existence remained hidden under the carpet) and welcomed them.
> Yuuki’s own attitude that forces nobody to follow her; made the nobles to trust her again especially at a time that her own brother was supposed to have betrayed the vampire race
>the noble kids that supported the co-existence project and ran to help her
> Kaien’s hate under the Kuran’s spell was cured
> Ouri, Shouto, Yuuri, Haruka, Yuuki are the proof that evil may exists but so is good.
>The hunters and Kaname had reached a common agreement> wasn’t that a liberation already from the old rules of the council and Asato’s faction that had corrupted anything?
After all we have reached the point that very few pureblood exist and apart from Sara we do not see and anyone actively participating in anything. So again what calls for such extreme measures?
How can Hino show that there was no other way after clearly showing all the above efforts for peace to shine through? After putting her main character to fight for this ideal? > if HW succeeds then apparently all other fail.
How can Hino justify it? IMO she cannot...because she has shown already the alternative > hans’t she?
So this amount of time and efforts could be another justification now for their elimination >> nothing changed in 10000 years; so what it could change in the future and how? Or think about how many indeed innocent lives had been destroyed during these 10000 years in order to be given second chances to these beings that are proven guilty and unchangeable …
You know what that reminds me?
{Other commentators have echoed the principle; Benjamin Franklin stated it as, "it is better [one hundred] guilty Persons should escape than that one innocent Person should suffer".[7]
John Adams also expanded upon the rationale behind Blackstone's Formulation when he wrote: "It is more important that innocence be protected than it is that guilt be punished, for guilt and crimes are so frequent in this world that they cannot all be punished. But if innocence itself is brought to the bar and condemned, perhaps to die, then the citizen will say, "whether I do good or whether I do evil is immaterial, for innocence itself is no protection," and if such an idea as that were to take hold in the mind of the citizen that would be the end of security whatsoever."}
See all societies have wars and injustice and killings but no one endorses or can justify even the kill of the one innocent for the sake of having ten guilty exterminated. I can’t believe that Hino shall lead her script into such a mistake.
What i keep as a fact at this moment is that Kaname did stop the killing even of the one being innoncent from HW's wish....we shall see about the continuation.
» Our Kaname is here!! Vampire Knight memories chapter 38
» Vampire knight Memories 38
» Where to Find Vampire Knight Memories Translation
» The Final Countdown
» New VK Chapter is HERE!
» Links for Other Vampire Knight Forums and Sites that you like and enjoy!!
» VK Memories CH 6!
» VK Memories
» New VK Chapter SPOILERS!
» New VK Bonus Ch!!
» Translation of 'Fleeting Dreams'
» Bunko Editions
» New Vampire knight Extra
» The Musical (Original and Revive)
» NEW CHAPTER IN 2015?
» Newbie in the forum...
» Who do you think Yuki loves more: Kaname or Zero?
» Zeki or Yume?
» So What will happen of Kaname?